On a rainy night in October 2006, Paula Wilson and Kimberly McKenna disappear after a high school football game in Lexington, Nebraska never to be seen again. Police suspect foul-play, but the bodies were never recovered and the only suspect, Kevin Shipright, has a solid alibi in the form of his fellow classmate Lexy Dawson.

Twelve years later, Kevin is the Chief of the Lexington Police Department and Lexy Dawson is long gone. She left town after high school, went to college, graduated with honors, and moved into the home willed to her by her grandmother. A home far from Lexington and the secrets she and Kevin share. Lexy spends her days doing freelance work and her nights watching the sunset over the Nebraska plains. She’s made a life for herself. A quiet life where nobody will suspect the secrets she harbors.

Hope Allen is the host and lead investigator of the Netflix Original Series Small Town Mysteries, Solved. She prides herself on having solved every case. But Season Seven, with five Emmy’s under her belt, she takes on the case of a lifetime. A case about two girls having disappeared from a small town in Nebraska…or at least that’s what she thinks. What she finds is far more sinister than anything she could have imagined. Hope Allen finds herself in a game of cat and mouse that may not only ruin her career, but may cost her her life.